How to Check a Green Claim’s Source Before You Publish It

How to Check a Green Claim

How to check a green claim before it goes on your page

Someone sends you a line for the website. It says a technology cuts emissions by a stated amount, and it has a link beside it. You are about to paste it in. Between the link and your page sits a step that is easy to skip: opening the link and reading what it says.

This guide covers how to check a green claim by hand, so that you catch a bad one before a regulator or a reader does.

How to Check a Green Claim

Why check a green claim source

You may feel that a green claim you copied from a credible source is the source’s problem. The regulator does not read it that way. The Competition and Markets Authority’s supply-chain guidance says businesses need to “take steps to ensure that any environmental claims they make (whether directly, indirectly or by passing information from others on to consumers) are accurate and not misleading”. The same guidance says “an ‘innocent’ or unwitting breach is still a breach of the law”. Where you cannot get the information you need to check a claim, it says “you should consider whether you should make the claim differently, in a way you can verify”.

The timing matters too. Rule 3.7 of the CAP Code, the advertising rules the ASA applies, says that “before distributing or submitting a marketing communication for publication, marketers must hold documentary evidence” to prove claims that consumers are “likely to regard as objective and that are capable of objective substantiation”. Whether a particular page counts as a marketing communication is a judgement. Claims on your own site about your own products and services are the obvious place to start from. The point for you is the order: evidence first, publication second.

And the stakes are real. The CMA has direct fining powers, and the penalty can be up to 10% of a business’s global turnover or £300,000, whichever is greater. These powers cover consumer law generally, not green claims alone, but the penalty exists.

Who answers for the green claim?

The short answer is that you do, whoever or whatever wrote the sentence.

If a drafting tool, AI or otherwise, produces your copy, the advertising regulator’s position is plain. The Advertising Standards Authority’s guidance for advertisers on AI tools says: “If an AI tool produces something problematic, the advertiser remains responsible for any output used in their ads”, and that advertisers must always sense-check outputs. That is an advertising statement, so whether a given page of yours counts as an advertisement depends on its context. It is not a claim that every blog post is covered.

The CMA’s supply-chain guidance says businesses “should be able to back up environmental claims with evidence”, and that where a claim cannot be verified you should consider making it differently, “in a way you can verify”. It was written for goods supply chains, and it describes repeating a supplier’s claim rather than publishing a tool’s draft.

We found no statement from either body that is specific to AI-generated green claims. Their position is that responsibility stays with the business that publishes and that the existing rules apply unchanged. Reading that across to drafting tools is our inference, a short step and an unremarkable one. A drafting tool changes how quickly an unsupported claim can be produced. It does not change who answers for it.

The five questions

Run these in order. Each one has a limit, and the limit is the useful part.

1. Does the cited page contain the figure or the phrase, in those words? Open the page. Search for the number and the keywords. If the claim has no figure, find the sentence that supports it. Limit: Finding the words proves the words are there, not that they mean what your sentence says. A number can sit beside the right words and belong to something else.

2. Is this the source, or a repeat of one? Follow the link upstream until you reach the body that did the measuring or made the rule. Round-ups, encyclopaedias and forums repeat; they do not originate. Limit: There is no official definition of a primary source for environmental claims. This is our own house rule, not a legal test, and you may reasonably set yours differently.

3. Does it mean what your sentence says? Check scope: “up to”, a region, a sector, a year, a model or version, a unit. Check for negation. A figure quoted for a different thing is the most common slip. Limit: this is a reading task. No tool does it for you.

4. Is it current? The CMA says “the evidence should be robust, credible and up to date”. So find the date on the page. Limit: A page’s displayed date may be its publication date or its last update, and some pages show neither. If you cannot date it, say so in your notes and treat it as unconfirmed.

5. Can you show your working? Write down the claim, the exact URL, what the page said, who checked it and when. Keep it where the next editor will find it. Limit: A note proves you looked, not that you were right. It makes the check repeatable, so the next editor can run it again. Our DMCC Act website compliance checklist makes the same point about recording what you checked and when.

What an automatic check can and cannot do

An automatic check, whether a tool you buy or a script you write, usually fetches the cited page and looks for the figure or wording near the claim’s keywords. It is good at questions 1 and 2 in their simplest form: no source at all, or a source with no sign of the claim. It cannot do the rest. It does not read meaning, so it misses negation, scope and a figure quoted for another purpose. It cannot tell an original from a repeat beyond a short list of known aggregators. It cannot tell whether a page is current. It does not read PDFs, images or charts, and it cannot get past a login.

A pass therefore means the words were found. It does not mean the claim is true, and nothing on your site is verified or compliant because a check passed. If you use any tool, treat its result as the start of question 3, not the end of the job.

A worked example: the green claim with no name on it

A figure for the internet’s share of global emissions has been widely repeated, and it appeared in our own posts. When we looked for a named, dated source behind it, we could not attach one. On 16 August 2026 we removed it from all 155 posts that carried it. We have not repeated the figure here, because repeating it would defeat the exercise.

Nothing about the figure looked wrong. It was plausible, familiar and everywhere, and that is how an unsourced claim travels. The test was simple: could we point at the page it came from? We could not, so it came out. You can apply the same test in a minute.

When the source fails

If a green claim fails any of the five questions, you have three honest options. Find the real source and re-check against it. Narrow the claim to what the source does say. Or remove it. The supply-chain guidance is direct about this.

Carbon claims about your own website are the case where this bites hardest, because the figures are modelled, not measured, and the model has to be named. If you are weighing up a supplier’s claims rather than your own, how to tell a sustainable agency from a greenwashing one is written for the buyer, and the safe-wording section of green website design myths shows what a defensible claim looks like once you have one.

Five questions about your process

The five questions above check one claim. These check the process around it. If anyone drafts your copy, human or tool, they are worth answering in writing.

  1. Who approves a claim before it is published? A named person, not “the team”.
  2. Where is the list of claims you are allowed to make? If the answer is “in someone’s head” or “in the last page we wrote”, you do not have one.
  3. Who runs the five questions, and where is the working kept? The page should contain the figure, not merely sit near the topic, and someone should have opened it.
  4. What happens to a number that fails? Decide in advance whether it is sourced properly, narrowed or removed, rather than softened with “around” or “up to”.
  5. Who can override a block, and how is that recorded? An override should come from the person accountable, explicitly, and not from a note inside the draft.

If you cannot answer three or more, the weak point is your process rather than your tools.

Where to start

If you want a worked method on your own site, our free website carbon audit reports page weight, modelled carbon per page view and the method behind both, so every figure comes with its working. An outside reading also helps, because the person who wrote a claim is the worst placed to find what is missing. For the wider picture of what a full review involves, see our website carbon audit guide and our website sustainability audits service, which establishes what your site can evidence so the claims you publish are the ones you can back.

Most common questions

01

How do I check a green claim before I publish it?

Open the cited page, find the figure or wording, follow it to the original source, and confirm that scope, date and units match your sentence. Then record the claim, the URL, what you saw and the date. The five questions above are that sequence, and each has a limit you should know before relying on it.

02

Am I responsible for a green claim I copied from a supplier?

Yes, on the CMA's supply-chain guidance, which says businesses need to take steps to ensure their environmental claims, "whether directly, indirectly or by passing information from others on to consumers", are accurate and not misleading. The same guidance says "an 'innocent' or unwitting breach is still a breach of the law". This is guidance on consumer law, not legal advice, and you should take advice on your own position.

03

What counts as a primary source for an environmental claim?

There is no official definition we could find. Our own rule is the body that made the measurement or the rule, on a page that contains the figure or wording you are using. Round-ups, encyclopaedias and forums repeat claims and do not count. Treat this as a house standard rather than a regulatory one.

04

Can software check a green claim for me?

Software can tell you the figure or phrase is missing from the page you cited, and that is useful. It cannot tell you the page means what you say, that it is the original, or that it is current. A pass means the words were found, not that the claim is true.

05

What if I cannot find the source for a claim I have already published?

Do not wait. Narrow the claim to what you can support, or take it down, and note the date and what you changed. The CMA says "you should consider whether you should make the claim differently, in a way you can verify".

06

How often should I recheck a published green claim?

We do not have a regulatory interval to give you. The CMA says "the evidence should be robust, credible and up to date". It gives no interval.

Set your own: recheck whenever the source page changes, whenever the figure feeds a new page, and on a schedule you set and record in advance.